5 Top Tips for Implementing Effective Quality Risk Management
Article By Michelle Yeomans, Operations Manager for EPiC Auditors
Quality risk management (QRM) is an integral part of GMDP that strives to protect patients by applying a scientific and practical approach to decision-making for different aspects of pharmaceutical quality throughout the product lifecycle.
The ICH Q9 QRM Guideline is referenced in Chapter 1 of EU GMP and reproduced in Part III of the guide and is intended to provide guidance on the principles, and examples of tools for QRM that can be applied to different aspects of pharmaceutical quality.
Following the Revision 1 update of ICH Q9 which became effective in July 2023, EPiC have been providing bespoke training and supporting clients as they assess and update their own PQS procedures in line with the changes to make QRM activities more effective and value adding.
ICHQ9(R1) provides multiple examples of potential applications of QRM, and If you have not done so already, we recommend you review the training materials on the ICH Q9 webpage https://www.ich.org/page/quality-guidelines and follow our top tips for effective QRM:
- QRM application – QRM can be applied anywhere there is potential risk across the business and across a product’s lifecycle. In applying QRM, it is important to ensure that patient safety and product quality considerations remain front and centre, as patients are putting trust in the decisions you make. QRM cannot be used to justify bad practice and non-compliance with GMP requirements.
- Risk Review – Be proactive and develop mechanisms to prompt reviews of existing risk profiles and control measures as your knowledge and experience increases. For example, set aside time at Quality Management Review meetings to review risk registers, review risk assessments associated with specific manufacturing processes, perform a review of engineering activities to confirm that planned preventative maintenance is on track and equipment is performing as expected, periodically review supplier performance and changes to confirm existing risk ratings are appropriate.
- Adopt a QA mindset – Design your processes to deliver a quality output rather than relying on problems/defects being detected at the end of the process. Provide training in the tools and techniques to the people involved in QRM activities and consider using experienced facilitators for more formal QRM processes.
- Think about the people involved – subjectivity can directly impact the effectiveness of risk management activities and the decisions made, so it is important to be able to recognise and control subjectivity, bias, assumptions, and mental shortcuts. This can be achieved by ensuring that risk questions are clearly defined, appropriate QRM tools are applied, and by being objective and evidenced based when assessing data and proposed control measures.
- Apply critical thinking – Critical thinking requires us to actively engage our brain to be able to work out complex problems. In working through the risk assessment, risk control and risk review phases of QRM, think clearly and rationally to understand the logical connection between ideas. Use the Q9 QRM toolkit to provide a systematic approach to identify, analyse, and solve problems rather than using intuition or instinct, but be prepared to question ideas and assumptions rather than accepting at face value e.g. is the tool fit for purpose, does the output seem right?
Effective and proactive QRM can enable better, more informed, and timely decisions throughout the product lifecycle, and we hope that our top tips will provide you with some useful ideas on how to further enhance your QRM processes. Â
Get in touch if you want to know more about our bespoke QRM and critical thinking training.
Telephone: +44 (0)1244 980544 or email us at enquiries@epic-auditors.com